Schnelligkeit von read vs. dim

Übersicht

BlitzBasic

Beginners-Corner

	lastking Betreff: Schnelligkeit von read vs. dim	Di, März 02, 2010 15:05 Antworten mit Zitat
Es macht doch bestimmt mehr Sinn, Daten vor der Hauptschleife mit read in ein Array zu laden und das dann anzufragen, als wärend des Schleifendurchgangs ständig restore/read zu benutzen oder? Es handelt sich um ein paar mehr Werte, könnte sein das es weit über 100-1000 werden... lg

lastking

Betreff: Schnelligkeit von read vs. dim

Di, März 02, 2010 15:05
Antworten mit Zitat

Es macht doch bestimmt mehr Sinn, Daten vor der Hauptschleife mit read in ein Array zu laden und das dann anzufragen, als wärend des Schleifendurchgangs ständig restore/read zu benutzen oder?

Es handelt sich um ein paar mehr Werte, könnte sein das es weit über 100-1000 werden...

lg

	Nicdel	Di, März 02, 2010 15:09 Antworten mit Zitat
Ja, sollte sehr viel schneller sein.
Desktop: Intel Pentium 4 2650 Mhz, 2 GB RAM, ATI Radeon HD 3850 512 MB, Windows XP Notebook: Intel Core i7 720 QM 1.6 Ghz, 4 GB DDR3 RAM, nVidia 230M GT, Windows 7

Nicdel

Di, März 02, 2010 15:09
Antworten mit Zitat

Ja, sollte sehr viel schneller sein.

Desktop: Intel Pentium 4 2650 Mhz, 2 GB RAM, ATI Radeon HD 3850 512 MB, Windows XP
Notebook: Intel Core i7 720 QM 1.6 Ghz, 4 GB DDR3 RAM, nVidia 230M GT, Windows 7

	Thunder	Di, März 02, 2010 15:57 Antworten mit Zitat
Es kommt darauf an, ob du die Werte nachher auch noch speichern willst. Wenn ja, dann nimm das Dim-Feld, aber ein Zugriff auf das Dim-Feld ist langsamer als auf die Variante mit Data und Restore. Dim verwendet nämlich wahrscheinlich die Funktion malloc() oder calloc() - das ist langsam. Data speichert die Daten direkt in der Datei, diese werden dann schon mit der EXE in den Ram geladen und müssen nicht über eine For-Schleife eingebaut werden. Mit folgendem Code habe ich das übrigens getestet(2300 Werte - Messung der Zugriffszeit): Code: [AUSKLAPPEN] [EINKLAPPEN] Local s,time,i,k,ntime Dim array(2299) Restore lab For i=1 To 2300 Read s array(i-1)=s Next Const durchlaeufe=50 time=MilliSecs() Restore lab For k=1 To durchlaeufe Restore lab For i=1 To 2300 Read s Next Next ntime=MilliSecs()-time ntime=ntime/durchlaeufe Print "Read: "+ntime time=MilliSecs() For k=1 To durchlaeufe For i=1 To 2300 s=array(i-1) Next Next ntime=MilliSecs()-time ntime=ntime/durchlaeufe Print "Dim-Feld: "+(MilliSecs()-time) WaitKey End .lab Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47
Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

Thunder

Di, März 02, 2010 15:57
Antworten mit Zitat

Es kommt darauf an, ob du die Werte nachher auch noch speichern willst. Wenn ja, dann nimm das Dim-Feld, aber ein Zugriff auf das Dim-Feld ist langsamer als auf die Variante mit Data und Restore.

Dim verwendet nämlich wahrscheinlich die Funktion malloc() oder calloc() - das ist langsam.
Data speichert die Daten direkt in der Datei, diese werden dann schon mit der EXE in den Ram geladen und müssen nicht über eine For-Schleife eingebaut werden.

Mit folgendem Code habe ich das übrigens getestet(2300 Werte - Messung der Zugriffszeit):

Code: [AUSKLAPPEN]

Local s,time,i,k,ntime
Dim array(2299)
Restore lab
For i=1 To 2300
Read s
array(i-1)=s
Next

Const durchlaeufe=50

time=MilliSecs()
Restore lab
For k=1 To durchlaeufe
Restore lab
For i=1 To 2300
Read s
Next
Next
ntime=MilliSecs()-time
ntime=ntime/durchlaeufe
Print "Read: "+ntime

time=MilliSecs()
For k=1 To durchlaeufe
For i=1 To 2300
s=array(i-1)
Next
Next
ntime=MilliSecs()-time
ntime=ntime/durchlaeufe

Print "Dim-Feld: "+(MilliSecs()-time)
WaitKey
End

.lab

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

	Noobody	Di, März 02, 2010 16:41 Antworten mit Zitat
Dass bei dir Read schneller ist, liegt daran, dass du die Zeit falsch misst. Beim Read-Durchlauf dividierst du ntime durch die Anzahl Durchläufe und zeigst die Variable dann an. Beim Dim-Durchlauf aber dividierst du ntime zwar durch die Anzahl Durchläufe, zeigst aber nachher nicht die Variable an, sondern (Millisecs()-time). Ausserdem hast du beim Dim-Durchlauf eine Subtraktion drin (array(i-1)). Das macht bei vielen Durchläufen einiges aus, also lass doch die Schleife von 0 bis 2299 laufen und nimm die Subtraktion raus. So ist Dim bei mir ca. doppelt so schnell BlitzBasic: [AUSKLAPPEN] [EINKLAPPEN] Dim Array( 2299 ) Restore Lab For I = 0 To 2299 Read Array( I ) Next Const Iterations = 5000 Local Time = MilliSecs() For K = 1 To Iterations Restore Lab For I = 0 To 2299 Read S Next Next Print "Read: " + ( MilliSecs() - Time ) Time=MilliSecs() For K = 1 To Iterations For I = 0 To 2299 S = Array( I ) Next Next Print "Dim-Feld: " + ( MilliSecs() - Time ) WaitKey() End .lab Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429 Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47 Und so nebenbei, Arrays verwenden malloc() nur beim redimensionieren, nicht beim Auslesen
Man is the best computer we can put aboard a spacecraft ... and the only one that can be mass produced with unskilled labor. -- Wernher von Braun

Noobody

Di, März 02, 2010 16:41
Antworten mit Zitat

Dass bei dir Read schneller ist, liegt daran, dass du die Zeit falsch misst. Beim Read-Durchlauf dividierst du ntime durch die Anzahl Durchläufe und zeigst die Variable dann an. Beim Dim-Durchlauf aber dividierst du ntime zwar durch die Anzahl Durchläufe, zeigst aber nachher nicht die Variable an, sondern (Millisecs()-time).

Ausserdem hast du beim Dim-Durchlauf eine Subtraktion drin (array(i-1)). Das macht bei vielen Durchläufen einiges aus, also lass doch die Schleife von 0 bis 2299 laufen und nimm die Subtraktion raus.

So ist Dim bei mir ca. doppelt so schnell BlitzBasic: [AUSKLAPPEN]

Dim Array( 2299 )

Restore Lab
For I = 0 To 2299
	Read Array( I )
Next

Const Iterations = 5000

Local Time = MilliSecs()

For K = 1 To Iterations
	Restore Lab
	
	For I = 0 To 2299
		Read S
	Next
Next
Print "Read: " + ( MilliSecs() - Time )

Time=MilliSecs()
For K = 1 To Iterations
	For I = 0 To 2299
		S = Array( I )
	Next
Next

Print "Dim-Feld: " + ( MilliSecs() - Time )

WaitKey()
End




.lab


Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Data 50,20,15,12,582,483,1729,183,28,1829,1,38429
Data 28,5910,1948,15028,487291,47,482,5,8,2841,47

Und so nebenbei, Arrays verwenden malloc() nur beim redimensionieren, nicht beim Auslesen Wink

Man is the best computer we can put aboard a spacecraft ... and the only one that can be mass produced with unskilled labor. -- Wernher von Braun

	Goodjee	Di, März 02, 2010 16:53 Antworten mit Zitat
und wer liest schon nen array nur von vorne bis hinten aus? was passiert, wenn du einen wert in der mitte willst? bei read brauchst du eine schleife oder viele sprungmarken, bei dims kannst du einfach direkt das richtige element adressieren
"Ideen sind keine Coladosen, man kann sie nicht recyclen"-Dr. House http://deeebian.redio.de/ http://goodjee.redio.de/

Goodjee

Di, März 02, 2010 16:53
Antworten mit Zitat

und wer liest schon nen array nur von vorne bis hinten aus? was passiert, wenn du einen wert in der mitte willst? bei read brauchst du eine schleife oder viele sprungmarken, bei dims kannst du einfach direkt das richtige element adressieren

"Ideen sind keine Coladosen, man kann sie nicht recyclen"-Dr. House
http://deeebian.redio.de/ http://goodjee.redio.de/

	Thunder	Di, März 02, 2010 16:56 Antworten mit Zitat
Tja, ich habe schon lange nicht mehr mit BB programmiert - tut mir leid, wegen der falschen Aussage. Goodje hat natürlich auch Recht. Aber Noobody: Da mit dem malloc() (bzw. calloc()) bist du dir ganz sicher? Wie sollte der Speicher für die Dim-Felder bereitgestellt werden, wenn malloc() nicht ausgeführt wird? mfg Thunder
Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

Thunder

Di, März 02, 2010 16:56
Antworten mit Zitat

Tja, ich habe schon lange nicht mehr mit BB programmiert - tut mir leid, wegen der falschen Aussage.
Goodje hat natürlich auch Recht.

Aber Noobody: Da mit dem malloc() (bzw. calloc()) bist du dir ganz sicher? Wie sollte der Speicher für die Dim-Felder bereitgestellt werden, wenn malloc() nicht ausgeführt wird?

mfg Thunder

Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

	Noobody	Di, März 02, 2010 17:17 Antworten mit Zitat
Thunder hat Folgendes geschrieben: Wie sollte der Speicher für die Dim-Felder bereitgestellt werden, wenn malloc() nicht ausgeführt wird? malloc() wird ausgeführt, nämlich jedesmal, wenn ein Array erstellt oder neu dimensioniert wird. Wenn du Dim Foo( 500 ) schreibst, wird Platz für 501 Elemente geschaffen. Dieser Platz ist immer da und muss nicht bei der Zuweisung eines Wertes neu geholt werden. Darum ist die Art, wie der Speicher des Arrays geholt wird, beim Auslesen/Schreiben komplett egal.
Man is the best computer we can put aboard a spacecraft ... and the only one that can be mass produced with unskilled labor. -- Wernher von Braun

Noobody

Di, März 02, 2010 17:17
Antworten mit Zitat

Thunder hat Folgendes geschrieben:

Wie sollte der Speicher für die Dim-Felder bereitgestellt werden, wenn malloc() nicht ausgeführt wird?

malloc() wird ausgeführt, nämlich jedesmal, wenn ein Array erstellt oder neu dimensioniert wird. Wenn du Dim Foo( 500 ) schreibst, wird Platz für 501 Elemente geschaffen. Dieser Platz ist immer da und muss nicht bei der Zuweisung eines Wertes neu geholt werden. Darum ist die Art, wie der Speicher des Arrays geholt wird, beim Auslesen/Schreiben komplett egal.

Man is the best computer we can put aboard a spacecraft ... and the only one that can be mass produced with unskilled labor. -- Wernher von Braun

	lastking	Di, März 02, 2010 18:09 Antworten mit Zitat
okay, vielen Dank für die Erklärungen!! Ich finds top, dass man hier so schnell Leute hat, die einem jede Frage beantworten... Der Aspekt von Goodjee ist natürlich ein sehr guter Grund für Dims...! Hat ich noch garnicht drüber nachgedacht, ob ich das noch brauche. Vorerst läuft die List enämlich bei mir durch. Für eine Bilanz. Bis denn!

lastking

Di, März 02, 2010 18:09
Antworten mit Zitat

okay, vielen Dank für die Erklärungen!! Wink

Ich finds top, dass man hier so schnell Leute hat, die einem jede Frage beantworten... Very Happy

Der Aspekt von Goodjee ist natürlich ein sehr guter Grund für Dims...!
Hat ich noch garnicht drüber nachgedacht, ob ich das noch brauche. Vorerst läuft die List enämlich bei mir durch. Für eine Bilanz.

Bis denn!

	Thunder	Di, März 02, 2010 18:32 Antworten mit Zitat
@Noobody: Ja, aber ich war überrascht, weil du geschrieben hast, dass malloc() nur beim redimensionieren aufgerufen wird. Anscheinend habe ich dich falsch verstanden. mfg Thunder
Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

Thunder

Di, März 02, 2010 18:32
Antworten mit Zitat

@Noobody: Ja, aber ich war überrascht, weil du geschrieben hast, dass malloc() nur beim redimensionieren aufgerufen wird. Anscheinend habe ich dich falsch verstanden.

mfg Thunder

Meine Sachen: https://bitbucket.org/chtisgit https://github.com/chtisgit

	Eingeproggt	Di, März 02, 2010 18:44 Antworten mit Zitat
Zitat: Vorerst läuft die List enämlich bei mir durch. Für eine Bilanz. Eine Bilanz von nicht-dynamschien Daten (=Data) zu machen ist aber sehr witzlos - da könntest du das Ergebnis deiner Bilanz doch auch gleich als Data ins Programm einbinden - Spart dir Rechnerei und Aufwand. Die Rechnerei ergibt ja logischerweise nur dann Sinn wenn sich die Daten ändern können (sprich erst recht in nem Array sind - was deine erste Frage klar beantwortet). mfG, Christoph.
Gewinner des BCC 18, 33 und 65 sowie MiniBCC 9

Eingeproggt

Di, März 02, 2010 18:44
Antworten mit Zitat

Zitat:

Vorerst läuft die List enämlich bei mir durch. Für eine Bilanz.

Eine Bilanz von nicht-dynamschien Daten (=Data) zu machen ist aber sehr witzlos - da könntest du das Ergebnis deiner Bilanz doch auch gleich als Data ins Programm einbinden - Spart dir Rechnerei und Aufwand.

Die Rechnerei ergibt ja logischerweise nur dann Sinn wenn sich die Daten ändern können (sprich erst recht in nem Array sind - was deine erste Frage klar beantwortet).

mfG, Christoph.

Gewinner des BCC 18, 33 und 65 sowie MiniBCC 9

Übersicht

BlitzBasic

Beginners-Corner

Nach Oben

BlitzBasic Portal

Schnelligkeit von read vs. dim

Betreff: Schnelligkeit von read vs. dim